Children & Adolescents

Icon

Neurodevelopment

Structural

Structural

Functional

Functional

Brain growth

After birth, neurons of the cerebral cortex - the folded outer layer of the brain, containing specialised functional areas - multiply quickly, developing the primary areas within it, such as the primary auditory and primary motor cortices. 

0

'Thoughts' begin 

Purposeful - 'concious' - movements and reactions begin to appear in response to the environment. 

Maximum growth begins

The highest rate of brain growth, the sensitive period, begins at around 2. Alongside this, neuroplasticity is at its maximum, the brain easily shaped by new experiences. Growth is particularly high in the prefrontal cortex. 

2

'Understanding' begins 

Higher-order cognitive functions, such as creativity and decision making, begin to develop

The brain gets faster

More neurons begin to be wrapped in myelin, a blanket-like layer of cells, allowing their signals to travel faster. 

 

 

4

'Coordination' begins 

The faster speed of the brain allows for quicker reactions and more controlled movements. 

Maximum growth ends

Basic areas such as the primary motor and auditory cortices are well developed and at a high level of function. Corpus callosum at its most impressionable. Brain growth begins to slow and neuroplasticity decreases. 

7

Sensory & Motor skills ✔️

Basic awareness of the surroundings and the body's movement within it is well established. Communication between brain halves developing. 

More specialised growth begins

Areas all around and within the brain continue to develop and begin to mature, such as the secondary auditory area of the cerebral cortex and the internal hippocampus. 

11

'Specialisation' begins   

Cognitive executive functions begin to develop and mature: inhibition and working memory by age 9, whilst cognitive flexibility continues to develop later into adolescence. More controlled socio-emotional function begins such as emotional regulation. 

More specialised growth continues

More complex areas such as the secondary auditory cortex, and internal structures such as the hippocampus, begin to mature. 

18

'Refinement' begins 

Further specialisation of more complex motor and sensory function, alongside further development and regulation of cognitive and socio-emotional function continues. 

More specialised growth ends

The brain is fully developed to its adult form. Growth and neuroplasticity are minimal. 

25

Cognitive and Socio-emotional skills ✔️

Complex, or 'higher-order', cognitive functions such as decision making, and socio-emotional skills such as empathy, are matured. 

Icon

... with Musical Instrument Training

Practice makes perfect

Music shapes the brain via neuroplasticity; small changes accumulating with practice. 1 year of training enhances brain communication, 4 years makes structures visibly larger (see below), a change believed to remain into adulthood, and continued practice, enhances and spreads these changes (see here). 

7 is the magic number

Evidence suggests musical instrument training has the largest, and most long-lasting, effect in those who begin before 7, enhancing both structural and functional outcomes. From ages 2 to 7 - the sensitive period of brain growth - neuroplasticity is at its highest making the brain the most easy to shape with external stimuli. 

All functions near & far

Learning to play an instrument mainly engages the sensory and motor areas, therefore, these regions are the first to exhibit changes - improvements in musically-related skills termed near-transfer effects. With long-term practice, evidence suggests changes to less musically-related areas may occur - far-transfer effects. 

Changes in brain health & their structures - the evidence

Accordion
  • Increased listening and visuospatial skills
  • Increased listening and visuospatial skills

    The sensory system is highly involved in instrument playing and many of its regions are primary, meaning they mature at an earlier age. Therefore, noticeable changes can appear here more quickly. 

    1. Somatosensory cortex - faster maturation, increased grey matter --> improved visual & spatial skills, or 'coordination'. 

    2. Primary auditory cortex - increased activation in response to sounds, increased grey matter --> improved 'listening'. 

    3. Secondary auditory cortex - increased activation in response to sounds, faster maturation --> increased control over attention up to age 13, becomes similar by age 16 (when it reaches full maturation in non-musical adolescence). 

    4. Corpus callosum - increased grey matter --> faster communication between the sensory (and motor) areas across the brain to understand more aspects of the sound. 

    This evidence suggests that musical children may be more attentive to sounds and so practically better listeners. 

  • Increased control of movement
  • Increased control of movement

    The motor system is highly involved in musical instrument playing and so is the first to be affected - 'near-transfer' effects. As the primary motor cortex is one of the first regions to mature, early music training can have a big impact. 

    Primary Motor Cortex – accelerated maturation, increased grey matter --> improves control, or 'coordination', of the body (hand and finger movement especially) 

    2 Premotor Cortex – accelerated maturation --> improves planning and organisation of movements 

    3 Basal Ganglia – no change (may be because the basal ganglia takes longer to develop) 

    4 Corpus Callosum – increase grey matter --> increased coordination of left and right sides of the body  

    5 Cerebellum – no change (may be because the cerebellum takes longer to develop) 

    This evidence suggests that musical children may have improved physical coordination, particularly in the hands and fingers (musically-related areas). However, maturation of the basal ganglia and cerebellum later in development may allow more fine tuning of these skills. 

  • Increased inhibition, memory, and language skills
  • Increased inhibition, memory, and language skills

    Simple musical training involves the sensory and motor regions, whereas the cognitive regions join with more complex practice. The main parts of the cognitive system (mentioned below) also mature a lot later in neurodevelopment as they are all highly specialised. Therefore, smaller, but nevertheless noticeable, changes appear in childhood cognition. 

    1 Prefrontal Cortex – increased activation, accelerated maturation --> EFs: 

    - Inhibition - improved, larger later rewards favoured over short term ones 

    - Working memory - improved language skills and task engagement with short-term memory

    - Cognitive flexibility - no change (cognitive flexibility is the last EF to mature, developing into late adolescence) 

    2 Broca’s area – stronger activation --> improved language skills  

    3 Basal Ganglia – no change (the basal ganglia matures later) 

    4 Cingulate Cortex – no change (the cingulate cortex matures later) 

    5 Corpus Callosum – increased grey matter --> 'faster' thinking 

    6 Hippocampus – increased activation, increased grey matter --> improved long-term memory 

    This evidence suggests musical children to have increased attentional control and language skills which some have linked to increased academic performance and higher IQs. The favouring of larger later rewards may transfer to more manageable classroom behaviour. 

  • Increased emotional regulation and conflict resolution
  • Increased emotional regulation and conflict resolution

    The socio-emotional system is not directly involved in musical training, therefore any change here is a far-transfer effect and takes longer to appear. However, significant changes have been seen in the emotional presentation of musical children: 

    Prefrontal Cortex – increased activation, accelerated maturation --> improved impulse regulation and conflict resolution 

    2 Cingulate Cortex – no change (matures later) 

    3 Basal Ganglia – no change (matures later) 

    4 Hippocampus – increased activation, increased grey matter --> increased emotional processing and regulation 

    This evidence suggests musical children may have increased self-awareness and interpersonal skills, however these may benefit from further regulation once the more specialised brain parts mature. 

  • Increased behavioural control
  • Increased behavioural control

    The behavioural system is the application of the sensory, motor, cognitive, and socio-emotional systems. Therefore, the increased function of those will all improve a child's behavioural skills. A few of the main features are highlighted below: 

    Prefrontal Cortex – increased activation, accelerated maturation --> improved impulse control and emotional regulation 

    2 Cingulate Cortex – no change 

    3 Basal Ganglia – no change 

What about children with abnormal neurodevelopment?

ADHD

Children with attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) often appear less organised, more fidgety and more emotional than their neurotypical peers. Research suggests that this may be due to abnormal development in key brain areas:

- Prefrontal cortex - slower maturation and decreased grey matter --> decreased EFs and emotional regulation  

- Cerebellum - decreased grey matter --> decreased control of movements e.g., standing up during a lesson

- Hippocampus - decreased grey matter --> decreased memory and emotional regulation

By adulthood these differences decrease - adults with ADHD have more ‘neurotypical’ brains. As discussed above, musical instrument training has been seen to accelerate the maturation and increase the grey matter of these affected regions. Therefore, early musical training in those with ADHD may ‘speed up’ their brain’s growth allowing it to function more typically and decreasing their symptoms into adulthood.

Autism

From birth to approximately age 2, research suggests that the brains of children with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) grow rapidly compared to neurotypical peers. This growth then slows, as neurotypical growth and shaping picks up, leaving the brains of autistic children larger and less shaped. As ASD is such a spectrum, common structural differences are hard to find, however, autistic brains do seem to have less activation and communication in some key areas such as the prefrontal cortex and cerebellum. This decrease in activity may explain the social and processing difficulties common in ASD. 

As discussed above, musical instrument training increased the activation of these brain areas, from a year of training. Therefore, training in a child with ASD may increase their brain activity and function to a 'typical' level, and decrease their symptoms. 

Icon

How could this benefit neurodevelopment & education?

As discussed above, evidence suggests that musical instrument training may accelerate and enhance neurodevelopment and increase children's brain function to a more 'adult-like' maturity. It may also help children with neurodevelopmental disorders, such as ADHD, to function more 'typically', improving general classroom management. Overall, musical children may have 'healthier' brains, in particular, improved cognitive and socio-emotional skills benefitting students academic performance and interpersonal relationships. 

Icon

Read more about some of the studies mentioned ...

- Schlaug's effects of music training on the child's brain and cognitive development (click here) - compares the differences after 1 and 4 years of training 

- Putkinen's promises of formal and informal musical activities in advancing neurocognitive development throughout childhood (click here) - talks about faster maturation 

- Hudziak's cortical thickness maturation and duration of music training: health-promoting activities shape brain development (click here) - talks about faster maturation

- Chen's the relationship between early musical training and executive functions: Validation of effects of the sensitive period (click here) - talks about the change in exectutive functions and  sensitive period before 7 

Icon

What evidence is there for the role of music education in brain health throughout life?

Children and Adolescents

Children and Adolescents

CLICK HERE
Adults

Adults

CLICK HERE
Older Adults

Older Adults

CLICK HERE
Feedback here